Can you put a cake back in the oven to cook more?

By: Emma
Date: May 19, 2022
Time to read: 7 min.

Can you put a cake back in the oven to cook more?

How often have you asked yourself, “can I put a cake back in the oven to cook more?” If you’re like most people, it’s probably not something that crosses your mind. But what if someone tells you they did it? Would you be willing to give it a try?

Can you put a cake back in the oven to cook more? A simple answer to the main question of this blog post is both yes and no. Whether you can put the cake back in the oven or not depends upon several factors, including the type of cake you are baking, the texture of the cake, and the type of pan being used.

These determining factors are precisely what this blog post will explore. We’ll examine why some people want to do this and others might not. If you are ever curious about cooking food for an extended period, don’t hesitate to read on!

Type of cake	Can you put it back in oven?
Chiffon cake	No
Biscuit cake	Yes
Baked flourless cake	Yes
Carrot cake	Yes
Genoise cake	No
Red velvet cake	Yes
Strawberry shortcake with whipped cream	No

Table 1: Cake types and ability to rebake

Who cooked the first cake?

Before we get into the details of can you put a cake back in the oven, let’s explore a little history. The very first cake was cooked by accident.

According to legends, around 2,000 BC, King Hieron II of Syracuse baked cakes to celebrate a victory against Carthage. In honor of this event, the pastry chefs were honored with the “king cakes,” which they made by mixing flour, oil, and honey.

Today’s version of the cake is quite different. Nowadays, everyone associates the cake with sweet ingredients like sugar, chocolate, dried fruit, or even cheese.

Learn more: Can you cook microwave meals in the oven?

7 Factors that determine whether you can rebake cake in the oven!

So what are the factors that one must take into consideration before trying to rebake the cake? We’ll explore seven of them below.

Cake type

This is perhaps the most important factor because each type of cake has a different requirement when it comes to being baked. Some cakes have more oil than others so they can tolerate going back in the oven for a few more minutes without becoming dry or overcooked.

Cake texture

Cakes that are denser or have a tighter crumb will not be as forgiving as those with a looser crumb. If you put a dense cake back into the oven, it will likely become dry and heavy.

Cake size

A large cake will take longer to cook than a small cake. And a round cake will cook differently than a square or rectangle cake. So, if you’re wondering if you can put a cake back in the oven, you must consider these factors.

Oven temperature

If you are starting out with an oven that is already hot, you will have a much shorter amount of time in which to heat up the cake.

Before knowing which cake can be put back in the oven, let’s have a look at the first journey of a cake in the oven. The following table explains everything.

Cake weight	Temperature	Baking Time in Minutes
8 – 10 oz	375 F	18
14 – 18 oz	375 F	25
24 – 28 oz	360 F	35
32 – 40 oz	360 F	35

Table 2: Cake weight and baking time

Cake temperature

The temperature of the cake matters too because if it’s warm already then the cooking process will be sped up. This means that you can’t leave your cake out on the counter for a long time before baking it, or you’ll end up with a dense cake.

Pan type

Some pans conduct heat better than others so if you use a cheap aluminum pan then the heat will not be distributed evenly which means that some parts of your cake might cook faster than others.

Now that you know some of the factors that determine whether you can put a cake back in the oven or not, let’s explore some of the reasons why people might want to do this.

Reasons why people might want to rebake their cake!

After you learn the reasons why people might want to rebake their cake, you might be wondering how just putting it back in the oven would help.

Well, let’s explore some of the possibilities below.

Before serving

Some people put the cake back in the oven just because they want to serve it warm and fresh. If you want to serve a cake warm then just reheat the oven and put the cake back in for 10 more minutes.

After cutting it up

If you cut your cake before serving but would like to add on some more time to cook it, then go ahead and put your cake back in the oven. Just make sure that you put it at a lower temperature.

If you want to serve your cake warm and not hot, then put the slices back in the oven for 10 minutes at low heat. Just make sure that you don’t heat up any aluminum pans or else your cake might turn into a lump of coal. Y

After decorating it

You might want to reheat the cake after decorating it with cream cheese frosting, melted chocolate, or fresh fruits because this process will make the decorations melt and blend. However, keep in mind that you cannot leave your decorated cake out for too long before serving or eating or else your beautiful design will disappear.

Tips to put the cake back in the oven to cook more!

Now that you know some of the reasons people might want to rebake their cake let’s explore some of the tips that will help you do this successfully.

Tip 1: Make sure your oven is preheated!

Before putting your cake back in the oven, ensure that your oven is preheated and ready to go. This way, you’ll know that the cake will cook evenly and not burn.

Tip 2: Keep an eye on the temperature!

Make sure that the cake is at room temperature before baking it again. If it’s not, then put it in the oven for a few minutes until it is at room temperature so that the cake will cook evenly.

Tip 3: Keep an eye on the timer!

If you’re only going to put the cake back in the oven for a few more minutes, then make sure that you turn the oven down to a lower temperature so that the cake doesn’t burn.

Tip 4: Use an oven thermometer!

If you’re not sure about the accuracy of your oven, then it’s a good idea to use an oven thermometer to make sure that the temperature is correct. This way, you’ll know for sure whether or not your cake will cook evenly.

Now that you know some of the tips to put the cake back in the oven to cook more go ahead and try it!

Can you put brownies back in the oven to cook more?

Again, the answer is both yes and no! It depends on various factors. For instance, if the brownie is undercooked, you can put it back in the oven to cook more. However, if your brownie is overcooked or burned, you cannot put it back in the oven to try and salvage it. If you want to find out some of the factors that affect whether you can put a brownie back in the oven or not, keep reading!

Here are some of the factors that affect whether you can put a brownie back in the oven or not!

Taste and texture

Can you put cookies back in the oven to cook more?

Yes, you can do this! However, if your cookie is overcooked, it might turn hard and crunchy. Also, if your cookie is burnt then it will be inedible.

Appearance

If your cookie is slightly undercooked, you can put it back in the oven to cook more without affecting its appearance too much. However, if your cookie is overcooked or burnt, it will be highly noticeable and not very appetizing.

Time

The longer you cook a cookie, the more likely it is to become overcooked or burnt. If you’re only going to be putting the cookie back in the oven for a few minutes, make sure that you turn the oven down to a lower temperature so that it doesn’t burn.

Watch: 5 Incredible Ways to Transform a Failed Cake

Final Thoughts

To sum it up, the answer to whether you can put brownies back in the oven or not depends on many factors. So, there is no definite answer to this question, but generally, it is acceptable to put a cake or brownie back in the oven if it is still hot and undercooked.

So either it’s your favorite cake or brownie, cook it more following the tips mentioned above and tricks.

Happy cooking!

Can you put a cake back in the oven to cook more?

Table of Contents